Close-up of two people shaking hands in an office
Photo by Kindel Media on Pexels

How do you tell if a marketing agency is legit? If you have been burned once, you already know the pitch can sound identical whether the agency is solid or a waste of money. Epoxy contractors are an easy target for agencies that promise big numbers and then send a monthly report full of impressions. A handful of checks, most of them free and none of them technical, will weed out most of the bad ones before you pay a cent.

Start with the business, not the website

Anyone can build a polished site in a weekend. Check the entity behind it. The Australian Business Register's ABN Lookup is free, needs no login, and lets you search by ABN, ACN or name. It shows whether an ABN is active or cancelled, the business type, the GST status and any historical trading names. If the name on the proposal does not match the name on the register, ask why. If the ABN is cancelled, walk away.

A real address and a phone number that a person answers are worth a call too. Ring the number before you book anything and see who picks up.

Check who will own your ad account

This is the check that matters most and gets asked least. On Meta, your Facebook Page, ad account and pixel should sit inside your own business portfolio, with the agency added as a partner. Meta's help centre describes adding partners to your business portfolio, such as an agency you work with, by giving them access to your assets. That is very different from an agency running your ads out of its own account and sending you a screenshot.

If the account belongs to them, you lose the history, the audiences and the tracking the day you leave. Ask the question directly: "If we part ways, whose account does the data sit in?" A legitimate agency answers in one sentence.

Look for proof you can verify

Real proof has names, places and specifics. Look at how the agency presents its clients. Our N&A Epoxy Flooring case study features an owner explaining that he had tried two other marketing agencies first, and the Triple A Epoxy Flooring case study breaks leads down by channel, job type and timeframe rather than quoting one big number. You can follow up either one with a call to the business.

Also check that the agency separates two things that get mixed up constantly. Lead volume is how many enquiries came in. Revenue is what the business earned. Our own Meta screenshots show lead volume only: a Sydney campaign with 86 leads at $19.00 each on $1,633.59 spent, and a Melbourne campaign with 38 leads at $19.31 each on $733.75 spent. They say nothing about jobs won, and we say so. An agency that blurs that line is hiding something you need to know. You can see the rest on our results page.

Read the contract before you read the pitch

Some agency contracts are a standard document you can only accept or reject, so read it properly. Look for the length of the term, what the notice period is, who pays for ad spend and whether it goes to the platform or through the agency. Look for any clause that lets the agency change fees without your agreement. Ask what you get on exit: the creative, the landing page, the account access, the lead data. If anything is vague, get it in writing before you sign.

Warning signs that cost contractors money

Reporting is where weak agencies show themselves. A tradie with a van to run does not need a forty page deck. You need to know how many real enquiries arrived this week, how many were answered, and how many turned into quotes. If a report cannot tell you that, it is not reporting on the thing you are paying for.

  • Promises of a specific number of jobs with no mention of your close rate or quote process.
  • Reports that show clicks and impressions but never leads, calls or booked quotes.
  • No way to see the actual leads: names, dates, suburbs and job types.
  • A generic "we do everything for every trade" offer with no epoxy knowledge.
  • Pressure to decide today, or an unwillingness to put the fee and term in writing.

A five minute test before you book a call

Before any call, search the agency name with the word "review", look up its ABN, and ask for two client contacts you can phone. Then ask three things: who owns the ad account, what exactly gets reported each week, and how to leave. Legitimate agencies answer all of that without fuss. If you want the wider checklist, our guide to choosing a marketing agency for an epoxy business goes further, and the Meta Ads for epoxy flooring page shows how we set accounts up.